The co-author, at Anthropic, quoting OpenAI's post back at itself. He had been silent all day: he was on neither of the calls, and everything said about him until now had been said by other people. Three things in it. He picks out the same hedge as the sentence worth reading and credits them for it. He has started reading the proof, which is the first public word from anybody outside OpenAI on what is actually in it, and his read is that it looks closer to a different Euler blowup proof he and Buckmaster already had than to the work they published. And he adds a detail about the calls that was not in Buckmaster's statement, which is his own account and nobody else has confirmed it: that a millennium prize was offered if he would be taken off the paper. What he does not do is take the fight, which is worth noticing on a page this long.
“we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our models.”
i mean props to them for straight coming clean.
(so far the proof looks more along the lines of another euler blowup proof we had, off of whose ansatz naming we were making really stupid puns like “smooth criminale”, unlike the much better “ideal fluids explode”, Tristan)
so i’ll now give a bit on my thinking here. i actually woulda been pumped to collaborate on this, there are a lot of people at oai i like (ok, clearly some were indirectly dicks to me because of being part of the whole situation, but im a big boy, i still like them), idgaf about authorship on that step anyway, coulda been me Tristan and every fte at oai for all i care (on that Tristan would disagree:p). but on hearing the loud convo in the hallway, especially the part where a millennium prize was offered if i’d just be removed from the paper, it was kinda clear the die had been cast and things were locked. pretty wacky, unstrategic, and unnecessary, since on my side things were mostly me and claude having a good time yoloing random stuff in the corner rather than anything institutional. i also like the idea of the labs cooperating, and even better on scientific progress. it’s a shame!
