Article · ~2,500 words, 12 minute read

"I scratched my own itch" isn't good enough

Jason Cohen · A Smart Bear (Jason Cohen, founder of WP Engine) Free Intermediate

This is the sharpest answer to the actual worry: Cohen names the sample-of-one problem directly and unpacks the seven hidden assumptions buried inside "I built it for myself." It does not tell you your itch is disqualifying, it tells you exactly which claims to go test before you trust it. Pair it with the Graham essay so you get both the case for and the honest cautions against building for someone exactly like you.

  • Your own itch is a hypothesis, not proof. You are a sample of one, and problems vastly outnumber real markets.
  • The trap is empathy, not passion: because you were frustrated enough to build, you are unlike the typical customer who just tolerates "good enough".
  • The fix is to interview real potential customers systematically instead of assuming they are like you, and to confirm they actively want a solution and have budget.

The question it answers

  1. Is it a red flag if my ideal customer is someone exactly like me?

Read with it

  1. A short, pointed essay on why the best ideas grow organically out of the founder's own life and knowledge, the essence of... paulgraham.com Article · ~5 min read Organic Startup Ideas Paul Graham
  2. A real founder talking through the exact tension in this question: Michael built PgMustard for a market rather than only... Indie Bites (the Indie Hackers short-form sister podcast) Podcast · ~20 minute episode The slow and steady path to growth (Michael Christofides, PgMustard) James McKinven (host), Michael Christofides (guest)
eChai Partner Brands The partnership →