Essay · About a 12 minute read

Why Most Online Communities Fail (and How to Build a Better One)

Justine and Olivia Moore · a16z (via Medium) Free Intermediate

Written by two consumer investors who have watched dozens of communities scale and stall, this essay makes the case that more members without more culture just means more noise, and that big-but-quiet communities become group chats everyone mutes. It is useful precisely because it pushes back on the instinct to treat member count as the scoreboard. Treat its prescriptions (curation, real onboarding, member investment) as a starting point to pressure-test your own growth plan against.

  • Measuring success by headcount is the trap: unchecked growth without a shared purpose produces zombie communities that are large on paper and dead in practice.
  • Curation and a slightly higher bar to entry protect culture better than open doors, because who you let in sets the tone more than any rulebook.
  • Onboarding and giving members a reason to invest early are what convert new arrivals into contributors instead of lurkers who quietly leave.
Open on medium.com ↗

The question it answers

  1. What are the most common mistakes founders make that quietly kill a community?

Read with it

  1. This is the cleanest checklist of the ways a community dies quietly, and it names the exact traps founders miss: chasing... Heartbeat Article · About a 10 minute read Why Most Online Communities Fail Murtaza Bambot
  2. Each episode sits a working community professional down to talk about the worst advice they followed and what it actually cost... Community Marketing Revolution Podcast · Episodes run roughly 30 to 45 minutes Bad Community Advice Seth Resler
eChai Partner Brands The partnership →