MVP · Starting Up
What is a concierge or Wizard of Oz MVP and when should I use one?
A concierge MVP means you deliver the service by hand, personally, for your first few users, while they think it's a product. It's the fastest way to learn whether people want the outcome without building the machine that produces it, and you often discover the real product is nothing like what you planned. Use it whenever the promise is a result (a matched vendor, a curated list, a done task) rather than a piece of software people need to touch every day.
Go deeper18 sources
-
The Mom Test
Rob Fitzpatrick · momtestbook.com · Book · ~130 pages
The single best thing ever written on customer conversations. It teaches you to ask about the customer's life and past behaviour, not your idea, so you can't be lied to. If a founder reads one thing before talking to a single customer, it's this.
-
Do Things That Don't Scale
Paul Graham · paulgraham.com · Essay · ~15 min read
The permission slip to recruit users by hand, do things manually, and deliver 'insanely great' experiences to your first few customers. The cheapest, most honest way to validate demand is to go get it one person at a time.
-
The Lean Startup
Eric Ries · theleanstartup.com · Book · ~330 pages
The origin text for the modern MVP and validated-learning vocabulary every founder now uses. Read it for the mental model that a startup is a series of experiments, not a single bet.
-
Learning from the Concierge MVP
Coleman McCormick · Res Extensa (Coleman McCormick) · Article
A tight, practical breakdown of what a concierge MVP is actually testing, using the Food on the Table example step by step. It makes the key point that the personal service is not the product, it is a learning activity aimed at your riskiest assumptions. Read it when you want the concept explained clearly without a book-length commitment.
-
How to Talk to Users
Eric Migicovsky · Y Combinator (Startup School) · Video · ~25 min
When you are new to a space, your instinct is to explain your idea and hope people nod, which teaches you nothing. This YC talk is a concrete guide to running discovery interviews the right way: extract data from the person instead of pitching, and use a small set of questions that work in any industry, including one you are still learning. It pairs well with The Mom Test as the applied version you can watch before your next call.
-
How to Plan an MVP
Michael Seibel (YC) · Y Combinator (YouTube) · Video · ~13 min
The single most-cited practical talk on scoping a first product, from the person who ran YC's accelerator. It cuts through the theory and shows what an MVP actually looks like using Airbnb, Twitch, and Stripe.
-
How to Build an MVP
Michael Seibel · Y Combinator Startup Library · Video · ~10 min video
Michael Seibel, who ran YC, makes the blunt case for shipping something almost embarrassingly simple and learning from real users instead of chasing a perfect first version. His line that if it takes more than a month to build, it is not an MVP is a practical yardstick for anyone stuck polishing. Watch it when the urge to add one more thing before launch takes over.
All 18 sources
-
Concierge vs. Wizard of Oz MVP
LogRocket · Article · ~12 min read
The two ways to fake a product while you test real demand. Do the work by hand in the open (concierge), or hide the manual work behind a front so users think it is automated (Wizard of Oz, the way Zappos started). Clear examples of when each one fits.
-
Wizard of Oz vs Concierge Testing: Behind the Curtain or Behind the Desk?
Amanda White · Mind the Product · Article · ~8 min read
This is the cleanest short explanation of the two manual-first MVPs and, more importantly, how they differ, which is where most founders get confused. Concierge means you are the visible front end doing the work by hand, Wizard of Oz means you have a real interface but a human quietly runs the back end. It walks a single concrete product example through both, so you can see which one actually answers the question you are trying to answer.
-
Wizard of Oz Prototyping vs. Concierge Test
Kromatic · Article
Kromatic works with corporate and startup teams on lean experiments, and this piece is precise about the difference and the failure modes of each. It helps you avoid the common trap of building fake automation when a simple human-facing service would answer the same question faster. A solid second read once the basic distinction has clicked.
-
Wizard of Oz Experiment (play)
Learning Loop · Template
A structured how-to you can follow, covering when to run a Wizard of Oz test, the steps, the tools, and the pros and cons. Treat it as a checklist so your experiment produces a clear answer instead of a vague feeling. Useful the moment you move from reading about the idea to actually setting one up.
-
Wizard of Oz (The Real Startup Book)
Kromatic (The Real Startup Book) · Template
This entry frames the Wizard of Oz test as one experiment in a wider validation toolkit, with clear guidance on cost, evidence strength, and how to run it. It is handy when you want to compare it against other experiments before committing time. A reliable reference for the founder who wants to run this properly rather than casually.
-
How Superhuman Built an Engine to Find Product/Market Fit
Rahul Vohra · First Round Review · Article · ~20 min read
Turns the vague feeling of product-market fit into a number you can move. Ask users how they would feel if they could no longer use the product, then track the share who say 'very disappointed'. Under 40 percent means keep working. A test you can run on an idea long before you scale it.
-
How Khadim Batti Built Whatfix Into a Global SaaS Leader
Prime Venture Partners · Prime Venture Partners Podcast · Podcast · ~50 min · India
An Indian founder story where the early demand test was manual, cold emails and direct outreach to find the first customers before the product had proven itself. It is a grounded counterpoint to the landing page: sometimes the fastest way to measure intent in a B2B market is to ask people to commit directly. Useful if your buyers are enterprises who will never fill in a consumer style waitlist form.
-
How to Launch an MVP
Michael Seibel and Eric Migicovsky · Y Combinator (Michael Seibel and Eric Migicovsky) · Video · ~45 min
A longer office hours style session where two YC partners answer real founder questions about scoping and launching a first version. Hearing them push back on founders who want to build too much helps you calibrate your own MVP. Watch it when you are stuck deciding what to cut before you launch.
-
What Is a Concierge MVP and When to Use It
Upsilon · Article
A practical walkthrough of when a concierge MVP is the right fit, when it is not, and how to actually run one. It is helpful for pressure-testing whether your idea (a delivered outcome versus daily software) suits this approach at all. Read it when you are deciding whether to reach for concierge or something else.
-
Getting Out of the Building: Customer Development
Steve Blank · Kauffman Entrepreneurs (Steve Blank) · Article · 10 min read
Steve Blank coined get out of the building, and this is a clean primer on why talking to customers is a search for facts your building cannot give you. It frames customer discovery as testing your assumptions against real people rather than defending a plan. A short, foundational read on why you are doing this at all.
-
The Minimum Viable Product: A Primer
Eric Ries · Eric Ries (Medium) · Article
If you do not want to read the whole book, this is Ries in his own words defining the MVP in a few pages. His guiding rule is to strip out anything that does not add to the learning you are after, which is exactly the logic behind delivering the outcome by hand first. It is a fast way to get the concept straight from the source.