Article

For Meta Marketers, Automation Isn't Always The Advantage (But It's Complicated)

AdExchanger Freemium Advanced

AdExchanger is required reading in ad tech for a reason: this piece pushes back on the 'broad always wins' consensus and lays out when automation genuinely underperforms, a useful counterweight before you switch everything to Advantage+.

  • An 18-month study of 640 incrementality tests found Advantage+ Shopping Campaigns beat manual campaigns only 42% of the time.
  • When Advantage+ did win, gains were modest: about 12% lower incremental ROAS at 18% lower daily spend.
  • Automation gains are uneven and depend heavily on account history, catalog quality, and conversion volume, so test both approaches for your own account.
Open on adexchanger.com ↗

The question it answers

  1. Should I use detailed interest targeting or go broad with Advantage+?

Read with it

  1. A free, no login spreadsheet template for running structured creative tests, useful before you can justify paying for a tool... GrowthFullStack Template How to automate your creative testing for free in Google Spreadsheets GrowthFullStack
  2. Straight from Meta: explains exactly how Advantage+ detailed targeting expands past your chosen interests, and where it does... Meta Business Help Center Article About Advantage+ Detailed Targeting Meta
  3. Documents Meta's own mid-2025 move to fold many interest categories into broader groupings, the exact policy shift pushing... Meta Business Help Center Article Updates to Detailed Targeting Meta
  4. Meta's own free training walks through setting up an Advantage+ Sales campaign end to end, worth doing before you touch Ads... Meta Blueprint Course Maximize Performance with Advantage+ Sales Campaigns Meta
  5. Broad and Advantage+ only work as well as the purchase signal you feed them, this is the reference for getting Pixel and... Meta for Developers Article Conversion Tracking (Meta Pixel Documentation) Meta
  6. Jon Loomer actually ran the A/B test rather than repeating platform talking points, so this is one of the few sources with... Jon Loomer Digital Article Test Results: Advantage+ Audience vs. Detailed Targeting and Lookalikes Jon Loomer
eChai Partner Brands The partnership →